New article on benefits and drawbacks of relying on advisors during family firm succession

What are the benefits of trusted advisor involvement during family firm succession? And what are the risks?

Succession is one of the most important but also most difficult parts in the family firm lifecycle. No wonder that many family firms build on the help of external trusted advisors such as lawyers, accountants or bank advisors, to help them managing the succession process. But what are the risks of such involvement? Under what circumstances are advisors beneficial and when are they detrimental? In our conceptual paper my co-author Alexandra Michel and I investigate this phenomenon in a paper forthcoming in Journal of Family Business Strategy.

Short summary:

  • The succession process consists of several steps — trigger, selection, preparation, and training. (see Figure 1)
  • In each of the phases, the trusted advisor can support the succession process by sharing information (“reducing information asymmetry”) and by mediating conflicts. Moreover, the advisor can contribute important process-and task-related knowledge. For instance, s/he knows about typical time frames, best practice solutions, etc.
  • However, in each of the phases, the trusted advisor can also hinder the succession process. This happens when s/he doesn’t equally distribute the information (but prefers one of the parties), if s/he is unable to mediate conflicts, or if s/he is too much focus on own agenda (e.g., neglecting emotional aspects and focusing on the “rationally” best solution).
  • The advantages of an advisor will dominate if there is a balanced triadic relationship between incumbent, successor, and advisor. The drawbacks will dominate if the advisor is biased. Bias can result, for instance, from being paid by one of the parties exclusively, by having a common private or professional history, or being of similar age and having similar interests. (see Figure 2)
  • A constellation with two (or even more) advisors does not solve the above mentioned problems of trusted advisor involvment but even makes them worse (see also Figure 2).

 

Succession process
Succession process

 

Advisor Constellations
Advisor Constellations

 

Access to full paper: here (then click pdf)

Citation of the paper:

A. Michel, N. Kammerlander. Forthcoming. Trusted Advisors in a Family Business’s Succession-Planning Process — An Agency Perspective. Journal of Family Business Strategy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s